To this
group belong the Brontosaurus and Diplodocus, the Camarasaurus, Morosaurus and
other less known kinds. All of them lived during the late Jurassic and Comanchic
("Lower Cretaceous") and belong to the older of the two principal Dinosaur
faunas. They were contemporaries of the Allosaurus and Megalosaurus, the
Stegosaurus and Iguanodon, but unlike the Carnivorous and Beaked Dinosaurs they
became wholly extinct before the Upper or true Cretacic, and left no relatives
to take part in the final epoch of expansion and prosperity of the dinosaurian
race at the close of the Reptilian era.
The following description of the Brontosaurus
skeleton in the American Museum was first published in
the American Museum Journal of April,
1905:[11]
"The Brontosaurus skeleton, the principal feature of
the hall, is sixty-six feet eight inches long. (The
weight of the animal when alive is estimated by W.K.
Gregory at 38 tons). About one-third of the skeleton
including the skull is restored in plaster modelled
or cast from other incomplete skeletons. The
remaining two-thirds belong to one individual,
except for a part of the tail, one shoulder-blade
and one hind limb, supplied from another skeleton of
the same species.
"The skeleton was discovered by
Mr. Walter Granger of the Museum expedition of 1898,
about nine miles north of Medicine Bow, Wyoming. It
took the whole of the succeeding summer to extract
it from the rock, pack it, and ship it to the
Museum. Nearly two years were consumed in removing
the matrix, piecing together and cementing the
brittle and shattered petrified bone, strengthening
it so that it would bear handling, and restoring the
missing parts of the bones in tinted plaster. The
articulation and mounting of the skeleton and
modelling of the missing bones took an even longer
time, so that it was not until February, 1905, that
the Brontosaurus was at last ready for exhibition.
Fig.
21.—Excavating the
Brontosaurus skeleton. The upper photograph
shows the anterior ribs of one side still lying
in position. The backbone is being prepared for
removal, the sections each containing three
vertebrae, partly cased in plaster and burlap
(see chapter XI.) The lower photograph shows a
later stage of progress, the blocks being
undercut and nearly ready to turn over and
incase the under side. Strips of wood have been
pasted into each section to strengthen it.
"It will appear, therefore, that the collection,
preparation and mounting of this gigantic fossil has
been a task of extraordinary difficulty. No museum
has ever before attempted to mount so large a fossil
skeleton, and the great weight and fragile character
of the bones made it necessary to devise especial
methods to give each bone a rigid and complete
support as otherwise it would soon break in pieces
from its own weight. The proper articulating of the
bones and posing of the limbs were equally difficult
problems, for the Amphibious Dinosaurs, to which
this animal belongs, disappeared from the earth long
before the dawn of the Age of Mammals, and their
nearest relatives, the living lizards, crocodiles,
etc., are so remote from them in either proportions
or habits that they are unsatisfactory guides in
determining how the bones were articulated and are
of but little use in posing the limbs and other
parts of the body in positions that they must have
taken during life. Nor among the higher animals of
modern times is there one which has any analogy in
appearance or habits of life to those which we have
been obliged by the study of the skeleton to ascribe
to the Brontosaurus.
"As far as the backbone and ribs were concerned,
the articulating surfaces of the bones were a
sufficient guide to enable us to pose this part of
the skeleton properly. The limb joints, however, are
so imperfect that we could not in this way make sure
of having the bones in a correct position. The
following method, therefore, was adopted.
"A dissection and thorough study was made by the
writer, with the assistance of Mr. Granger, of the
limbs of alligators and other reptiles, and the
position, size and action of the principal muscles
were carefully worked out. Then the corresponding
bones of the Brontosaurus were studied, and the
position and size of the corresponding muscles were
worked out, so far as they could be recognized from
the scars and processes preserved on the bone. The
Brontosaurus limbs were then provisionally
articulated and posed, and the position and size of
each muscle were represented by a broad strip of
paper extending from its origin to its insertion.
The action and play of the muscles on the limb of
the Brontosaurus could then be studied, and the
bones adjusted until a proper and mechanically
correct pose was reached. The limbs were then
permanently mounted in these poses, and the skeleton
as it stands is believed to represent, as nearly as
study of the fossil enables us to know, a
characteristic position that the animal actually
assumed during life....
"In proportions and appearance the Brontosaurus
was quite unlike any living animal. It had a long
thick tail like the lizards and crocodiles, a long,
flexible neck like an ostrich, a thick short,
slab-sided body and straight, massive, post-like
limbs suggesting the elephant, and a remarkably
small head for the size of the beast. The ribs,
limb-bones and tail-bones are exceptionally solid
and heavy; the vertebrae of the back and neck, and
the skull, on the contrary are constructed so as to
combine the minimum of weight with the large surface
necessary for the attachment of the huge muscles,
the largest possible articulating surfaces, and the
necessary strength at all points of strain. For this
purpose they are constructed with an elaborate
system of braces and buttresses of thin bony plates
connecting the broad articulating surfaces and
muscular attachments, all the bone between these
thin plates being hollowed into a complicated system
of air-cavities. This remarkable structure can be
best seen in the unmounted skeleton of
Camarasaurus, another Amphibious Dinosaur." (The
scientific name Camarasaurus=chambered
lizard, has reference to this peculiarity of
construction.)
"The teeth of the Brontosaurus indicate that it
was an herbivorous animal, feeding on soft vegetable
food. Three opinions as to the habitat of Amphibious
Dinosaurs have been held by scientific authorities.
The first, advocated by Professor Owen, who
described the first specimens found sixty years ago
(1841-60) and supported especially by Professor
Cope, has been most generally adopted. This regards
the animals as spending their lives entirely in
shallow water, partly immersed, wading about on the
bottom, or perhaps occasionally swimming, but unable
to emerge entirely upon dry land.[12] More recently,
Professor Osborn has advocated the view that they
resorted occasionally to the land for egg laying or
other purposes, and still more recently the view has
been taken by Mr. Riggs and the late Professor
Hatcher that they were chiefly terrestrial animals.
The writer inclines to the view of Owen and Cope,
whose unequalled knowledge of comparative anatomy
renders their opinion on this doubtful question
especially authoritative.
After Osborn
Fig. 22.—Restoration
of Brontosaurus by C.R. Knight, under direction
of Professor Osborn.
"The contrast between the massive structure of
the limb-bones, ribs and tail, and the light
construction of the backbone, neck and skull,
suggests that the animal was amphibious, living
chiefly in shallow water, where it could wade about
on the bottom, feeding upon the abundant vegetation
of the coastal swamps and marshes, and pretty much
out of reach of the powerful and active Carnivorous
Dinosaurs which were its principal enemies. The
water would buoy up the massive body and prevent its
weight from pressing too heavily on the imperfect
joints of the limb and foot bones, which were
covered during life with thick cartilage, like the
joints of whales, sea-lizards and other aquatic
animals. If the full weight of the animal came on
these imperfect joints the cartilage would yield and
the ends of the bones would grind against each
other, thus preventing the limb from moving without
tearing the joint to pieces. The massive, solid limb
and foot bones weighted the limbs while immersed in
water, and served the same purpose as the lead in a
diver's shoes, enabling the Brontosaurus to walk
about firmly and securely under water. On the other
hand, the joints of the neck and back are
exceptionally broad, well fitting and covered with a
much thinner surface of cartilage. The pressure was
thus much better distributed over the joint, and the
full weight of the part of the animal above water
(reduced as it was by the cellular construction of
the bones) might be borne on these joints without
the cartilage giving way.
"Looking at the mounted skeleton we may see that
if a line be drawn from the hip joint to the
shoulder-blade, all the bones below this are
massive, all above (including neck and head) are
lightly constructed. This line may be taken to
indicate the average water-line, so to speak, of
this Leviathan of the Shallows. The long neck would
enable the animal, however, to wade to a
considerable depth, and it might forage for food
either in the branches or the tops of trees, or more
probably, among the soft succulent water-plants of
the bottom. The row of short spoon-shaped stubby
teeth around the front of the mouth would serve to
bite or pull off soft leaves and water-plants, but
the animal evidently could not masticate its food,
and must have swallowed it without chewing as do
modern reptiles and birds.
"The brain-case occupies only a small part of the
back of the skull, so that the brain must have been
small even for a reptile, and its organization (as
inferred from the form of the brain-case) indicates
a very low grade of intelligence. Much larger than
the brain proper was the spinal cord, especially in
the region of the sacrum, controlling most of the
reflex and involuntary actions of the huge organism.
Hence we can best regard the Brontosaurus as a
great, slow-moving animal automaton, a vast
storehouse of organized matter directed chiefly or
solely by instinct, and to a very limited degree, if
at all, by conscious intelligence. Its huge size and
its imperfect organization, compared with the great
quadrupeds of today, rendered its movements slow and
clumsy; its small and low brain shows that it must
have been automatic, instinctive and unintelligent."
Composition of the Brontosaurus Skeleton.
"The principal specimen, No. 460, is from the Nine
Mile Crossing of the Little Medicine Bow River,
Wyoming. It consists of the 5th, 6th, and 8th to
13th cervical vertebrae, 1st to 9th dorsal and 3rd
to 19th caudal vertebrae, all the ribs, both
coracoids, parts of sacrum and ilia, both ischia and
pubes, left femur and astragalus, and part of left
fibula. The backbone and most of the neck of this
specimen were found articulated together in the
quarry, the ribs of one side in position, the
remainder of the bones scattered around them, and
some of the tail bones weathered out on the surface.
"From No. 222, found at Como Bluffs, Wyo., were
supplied the right scapula, 10th dorsal vertebra,
and right femur and tibia.
"No. 339, from Bone-Cabin Quarry, Wyoming,
supplied the 20th to 40th caudal vertebrae, No. 592,
from the same locality the metatarsals of the right
hind foot; and a few toe bones are supplied from
other specimens.
Fig.
23.—Skull of Diplodocus
from Bone-Cabin Quarry, north of Medicine Bow,
Wyoming.
"The remainder of the skeleton is modelled in
plaster, the scapula, humerus, radius and ulna from
the skeleton in the Yale Museum, the rest
principally from specimens in our own collections.
The modelling of the skull is based partly upon
specimens in the Yale Museum, but principally upon
the complete skull of Morosaurus shown in another
case.
"Mounted by A. Hermann, completed Feb. 10, 1905."
When the first remains of these amphibious Dinosaurs
were found in the Oxford Clays of England, they were
considered by Richard Owen to be related to the
Crocodiles, and named Opisthocoelia. Subsequently the
finding of complete skeletons in this country led Cope
and Marsh to place them with the true Dinosaurs and the
latter named them Sauropoda.[13] Remains of these
animals have also been found in India, in German East
Africa, in Madagascar, and in South America, so that
they were evidently widely distributed. In the Northern
world they survived until the Comanchic or Lower
retaceous Period, but in the southern continents they
may have lived on into the Upper Cretaceous or true
Cretacic. Some of the remains recently found in German
East Africa indicate an animal exceeding either
Brontosaurus or Diplodocus
in bulk.
At the date of writing this handbook only preliminary
accounts have been given of the marvellous finds made
near Tendaguru by the expedition from Berlin. From these
it appears that in length of neck and fore limb this
East African Dinosaur greatly exceeded either
Brontosaurus or Diplodocus. The hinder parts
of the skeleton however, were relatively small. The
proportions and measurements given tally closely with
the American Brachiosaurus, a gigantic sauropod
whose incomplete remains are preserved in the Field
Museum in Chicago and to this genus the Berlin
authorities now refer their largest and finest skeleton.
If the Berlin specimens are correctly referred to
Brachiosaurus they indicate an animal somewhat
exceeding Diplodocus or Brontosaurus in
total bulk but distinguished by much longer fore limbs
and an immensely long neck—a giraffe-like wader adapted
to take refuge in deeper waters, more out of reach of
the fierce carnivores of the land.[14]